Stardew Valley – Forester or Gatherer? – Which One Should You Choose?

Stardew Valley provides a beautiful way to escape the modern world. The player is tasked with transforming a scraggly old farm into a thriving hub of activity while earning money from their efforts. With the gameplay being so robust, it is hard to know which profession would be best for your farm.

It will be risky to harvest crops without the art of harvesting. Foraging in Stardew Valley is collecting any berries or other natural edibles that spawn on the ground.

Harvesting crops from wild seeds is also known as gleaning. Gleaning has been used for centuries to increase biodiversity and collect produce from the wild.

As you go to Stardew Valley, you’ll be offered the option of becoming a Forester or a Gatherer. The forester specialises in growing trees for the player, while the gatherer focuses on gathering wild materials like herbs and berries. For best results, pick one profession to focus on and build more advanced farming techniques in that profession.

Here’s a rundown of all the information you need to know about Foraging:

Also read: The Best Sprinkler System Design for Stardew Valley

Foraging Levels in Stardew Valley: 1 to 4

  • Level 1: Inconspicuous Wild Carrots (Spring), Vegetation falls as ephemeral confections when chopped down.
  • Level 2: Survival Burger
  • Level 3: Tapper 
  • Level 4: Wild Seeds, Charcoal Kiln (summer)

Foraging is a good idea because wild seeds are random and can include any plant of that period.

The tapper removes valuable products from trees. For example, three days later, you can extract maple sap, pine tar or oak resin if you put a tap in a tree.

Each product is named after a tree on which the tap is turned on. An oak tree does not produce maple syrup! A tap will not drop when you cut down a tree. 

Eating a Survival Burger will improve your foraging skill by +3. It means you’ll have a better chance of finding high-quality. Instead, at Level 5, you are given a decision to become either a Forester or a Gatherer.

The Foraging Level 5 of Stardew Valley: Forest or Gatherer?

At level 5, the option to invest in Foraging or Gatherer will be available. Players will make a choice of which profession they want to specialize in, and it’ll earn them incentives throughout the game. 

Gatherer offers you the opportunity to duplicate forged harvest goods. You’re able to collect two items from one harvest, but only foraged articles, not your field.

The likelihood of receiving an identical product is 20%, meaning there’s not enough chance.

We have the opinion that Gatherer is the road to reach level 5.

The Forester gives the wood a bonus, but the Gatherer at level 10 and the Botanist at level 10 are two huge bonuses.

Within the early stages of the game, Forester is unequal because wood isn’t usually sold for profit.

The reason you may also start by collecting and selling a few of the logs is so that in future, you won’t do this anymore.

What’s more, you can’t gather a duplicate, so why choose a forester. It is not very beneficial to your crop at all. It is worth mentioning that it doesn’t matter which clan you choose. 

We need to learn about the unlocks available for level four and below before getting into what’s available for level 10.

Foraging Levels in Stardew Valley: 6 to 9:

  • Level 6: Lighting Rod, Wild Seeds (fall), Beach Warp Totem
  • Level 7: Warp Totem: Mountains, Winter Wild Seeds, Tree Fertilizer
  • Level 8: Warp Totem: Farm, plus +1 Wild Berry harvesting
  • Level 9: Rain Totem

The unlocks for Foraging levels 6 through 9 are pretty handy. You now have access to Warp Totems, which you may use to teleport to specific places. For the first time, you will also get your winter & drop Wild Seeds.

Level 10 Foraging in Stardew Valley: Tapper or Lumberjack? Tracker or Botanist?

At the skill level of Foraging 10, you’ll have the option of selecting between two more professions.

This option is dependent on your choice at level 5, so it’s best to prepare ahead before you read this. You can choose between Lumberjack and Tapper if you choose Forester.

Gatherer offers Botanist and Tracker. We recommend these two vocations for different situations.

Also read: Stardew Valley Secret Note 11 – Explained

Tapper or Lumberjack?

The decision between Lumberjack and Tapper is relatively simple. If you choose Forester, you’re probably looking to compensate for the shortage of hardwood that many players face in the late game.

Many gamers believe tapper is weak because the +25% sell value to syrup is virtually worthless.

For us, there is no contest: Lumberjack is vastly superior. Hardwood might be challenging to acquire and amass for structures in the late game, but Lumberjack can help.

Botanist or Tracker?

Botanists are at the top of the Foraging skill tree in terms of the most pleasing profession. Botanists ensure that all foraged goods are of the best quality possible is one way.

It implies they’ll always be of iridium or Gold grade. It is a reminder you received when you levelled up.

Seeds can produce a lot of high-quality plants. Imagine being able to grow corals, quartz, or other forageables for free.

Tracker is only a UI enhancement. 

It casts a beam onto the screen to indicate the position of forage or harvestable objects. When considered in contrast to Botanists, we don’t think it isn’t very safe.

Frequently, people find pressing arrows a nuisance because they have to squint, but by simply making a minor adjustment, we don’t have to squint, and we can see more of the screen.

So, what should I choose in Stardew Valley foraging professionals?

So in Stardew Valley, which route is suitable for you, Forester or Gatherer?

Tapper or Lumberjack? Botanist or scout? When it comes to the Foraging professions, we believe there is a clear winner. Gatherer is the best career route to choose, followed by Botanist. Gatherer’s twofold harvest, along with the Botanist buff, is an excellent way to obtain iridium or gold foraged items.

Since hardwood might be scarce after the game, Forester & Lumberjack are our second choice. Forester offers a slight advantage in terms of wood rate, but Lumberjack is much better for obtaining sap. If you don’t enjoy grinding hardwood, this might be a good alternative.

Stay in the Loop

Get the daily email from GameTaco that makes reading the news actually enjoyable. Join our mailing list to stay in the loop to stay informed, for free.

Latest stories

You might also like...